17-35 2.8 vs. 14-24 2.8

Discussion in 'Lens Lust' started by cvansickler, Jul 5, 2008.

  1. cvansickler

    cvansickler

    27
    May 17, 2008
    Texas
    Is the new 14-24 worth selling the 17-35 and buying.
     
  2. It really depends on your photographic style. When I bought my D3, and needed something to replace my DX 12-24. I ended up going for the 17-35mm for the following reasons:

    - it is smaller and lighter than the 14-24
    - it takes front filters
    - it doesn't have a protruding front element

    I also have the 16mm fisheye for when I want to get really wide.

    However, the 14-24 is definitely a stellar lens. I am still considering buying it further down the line - the definition, contrast, and sharpness the lens can deliver is something not matched by any of Nikon's other pro zooms, at least based upon the samples i have seen on NikonCafe. However for me the deal breaker was the inability to attach filters. I will probably end up with both one day though......
     
  3. drjiveturkey

    drjiveturkey Guest

    If you're into landscapes and like to use NDs or Polarizers, keep the 17-35 and get a 14mm prime. You cant put filters on the 14-24 unless you make a filter hold that attaches to the front. And when you do that it vingets a lot till about...17mm anyways.

    If you're not a filter user, than 14-24 would be a nice replacement.
     
  4. I know that eventually I'll have a 14-24.
    Resistance is futile. But still......

    I'll not get rid of my 17-35 when I get a 12-24.
    The 17-35 is my #1 favorite lens.
    The 20-30mm range is my home base.

    The 14mm is way wider and the 35mm is way longer.
    I believe this is not an either/or choice, as the ranges are so very different.


    here.....17mm image on top of the 14mm to illustrate.

    90023507.jpg
     
  5. PJohnP

    PJohnP

    Feb 5, 2005
    Throw the Sigma 12-24mm f/4.5-5.6 into the mix for consideration. If you're doing landscapes or WA cityscapes, it's the widest zoom available for FF shooting. I'm trying to find somebody I know who has it so that I can test it out for myself.



    John P.