70-200 f2.8 VR or 80-200 AFD

Joined
Jun 3, 2008
Messages
1,255
Location
London, England
Hi all,

i am sure this question has been asked to death yet here i am asking the question.

My 85 1.4 right now represents the longest lens i have with my D3 and would like to add a tele-zoom in the 70/80-200 (obviously) range. I will be using it predominantly for sports and weddings.

I am just wondering if the 70-200 is worth the extra money. I initially believed it did since the VR function will help overcome the slight shakes i get when my technique sometimes lets me down. However, since the D3 is outstanding in low light situations, surely increasing the ISO and thus the shutter speed will negate the need for VR. or is it better to have the VR and shoot at a little lower ISO. (sorry if that didnt make any sense, i cant think of any other way of phrasing it)

as far as i have gathered, optically they are equal in all respects (or have i been decieved?)

thanks in advance for all comments.

shing
 
Joined
Aug 11, 2007
Messages
749
Location
Milton, Ontario, Canada
I concur, the 70-200VR can be held at very slow shutter speeds thanks to the VR and the smaller size and sharpness of the lens makes it a winner.

AM
 
Joined
Dec 21, 2007
Messages
1,096
Location
San Jose, Ca
i concur too, if you're choosing between 70-200 and 80-200 AF-d the choice is easy, if you have the cash get the 70-200.
 
Joined
Apr 30, 2005
Messages
3,605
Location
Massachusetts
Real Name
David
I will be using it predominantly for sports and weddings. ..... I initially believed it did since the VR function will help overcome the slight shakes i get when my technique sometimes lets me down. However, since the D3 is outstanding in low light situations, surely increasing the ISO and thus the shutter speed will negate the need for VR. or is it better to have the VR and shoot at a little lower ISO. (sorry if that didnt make any sense, i cant think of any other way of phrasing it)

The focus of the VR version is what makes it worth the dollars. I have owned both and wouldn't go back to the 80-200.
I concur, the 70-200VR can be held at very slow shutter speeds thanks to the VR and the smaller size and sharpness of the lens makes it a winner.

AM
I've owned 2 80-200 AF-D lenses, 1 70-200 AF-S VR, and my second shooter has the 80-200 AF-S.

Since you added weddings, get the 70-200. Yes you can bump the ISO to get faster shutters, but you want to slow it down to balance any flash and ambient light. Also you almost always want the lowest ISO possible.

The difference in focus speed between the AF-S and AF-D versions is there but not that big a deal on a D200 (the body I had at the time) and on a D3 I really think you'd be hard pressed to notice (I tried them on a D2x).

If you are talking about the AF-D version and not the AF-S version of the 80-200. The 80-200 AF-D is by far the smallest and lightest. The AF-S version of the 80-200 is the heaviest of the 3.

80-200 AF-D 45.9oz, 7.4in. Long
80-200 AF-S 54.7oz, 8.15in Long
70-200 AF-S 51.9oz, 8.5in. Long
 
D

drjiveturkey

Guest
I had the 80-200 AF-S for about a 3 weeks then ran into a great deal on a 70-200 VR so sold it off. Couldn't be happier. I never ran any head to head test, but I'm happy with the performance of both and love the VR especially when panning. I came from canon so I'd been spoiled with USM and IS.
 
Joined
Dec 28, 2007
Messages
93
Location
Florida (mostly), USA
Haven't used the 70-200, but I have an 80-200 AFD. It's a great lens for the money. I don't use it low light much, but for sports I think it's great... sharp and fast focusing enough on my D200.
 
Joined
Feb 15, 2008
Messages
6,190
Location
Savannah, GA
I concur, the 70-200VR can be held at very slow shutter speeds thanks to the VR and the smaller size and sharpness of the lens makes it a winner.

AM
70-200 is longer and heavier than the 80-200 D.
Probably not the deciding factor however.
Fred
 
Links on this page may be to our affiliates. Sales through affiliate links may benefit this site.
Nikon Cafe is a fan site and not associated with Nikon Corporation.
Forum post reactions by Twemoji: https://github.com/twitter/twemoji
Copyright © 2005-2019 Amin Forums, LLC
Top Bottom