Any Sigma 10-20 mm experience ?

[debult]

Visiting Yellowstone in September.

Was thinking about an extension in the wide angle area.
Currently my 18-700 mm kit lens has the widest angle option.

Considerring Sigma 10-20 versus Tokina 12-24

The Tokina is well discussed in this forum.
Any experience on the Sigma ?
Is Nikon Capture CA correction able to correct for these lenses ?

Input appreciated

 

[allen_a_george]

There are a number of posts in DPReview. One that I found very interesting is:

http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1030&message=14667715

I have been looking for both a WA and a telephoto to complement my kit lens. I tried the Sigma out and it feels well built, with excellent quality. I am going back today with a CF card and my camera to take some photos.

Hopefully all will be positive.

 

[Rocha]

I am interested on this lens too, post some samples if you can!

Thanks,

Luiz

 

[obelix]

Can't talk about the Sigma, but I own the tokina. Capture's CA correction works on the tokina. See an example here:

http://www.anands.net/faq/tokina.html

 

[allen_a_george]

Will try Rocha. Looks like this lens is in very short supply in the GTA. I'm going to check tomorrow if the copy I saw is still in stock.

Cheers,
Allen

 

[debult]

Can't talk about the Sigma, but I own the tokina. Capture's CA correction works on the tokina. See an example here:

http://www.anands.net/faq/tokina.html

Thanks for the evaluation, usefull info in filter selection !

 

[debult]

The Sigma 10-20 is in stock at my supplier 500 Euros (The Netherlands).But he does not stock Tokina, so no change of comparison.....