Cafe Challenge #10 - Voting Thread

Discussion in 'Challenge and Contests Forum' started by Greg, Aug 14, 2005.

  1. Greg

    Greg

    909
    Apr 5, 2005
    Fayetteville, TN
    We have 27 entries to select from. A good showing with a dificult theme. All show merit of one sort or another. Your job is to select the top three that best depicts the theme of the challenge and has high technical marks.

    The winner chosen by you will receive 24 DVD's as the prize.

    We will follow the previous voting procedures which I have copied here for your reference.

    THE RULES FOR VOTING:

    Everyone is allowed three votes:

    1st place: 3 points
    2nd place: 2 points
    3rd place: 1 point

    Carefully look at each entry and ask yourself of each if 1, does it meet the theme of the challenge? 2. is it high in the technical quality and finally does it have an impact on you?

    Make sure to mention the name (member name and real name if different and provide by the poster) of the artist and the title of the artwork!

    Voting begins now and will end on Saturday - Aug 20, 2005 - at 23:59 utc/gmt standard time.

    To avoid time disputes here is the link to our time standard for this:

    http://www.worldtimeserver.com/current_time_in_UTC.aspx
     
  2. Greg

    Greg

    909
    Apr 5, 2005
    Fayetteville, TN
    Here are my choices.

    1st place and 3 points to Michael Shuster for "The Stare".
    2nd place and 2 points to Kevin Scott for "The End".
    3rd place and 1 point to Chris Heilman for "Pink Feathers".

    There were many good submitals but alas, only three can be selected.

    Good job all.
     
  3. eng45ine

    eng45ine

    May 11, 2005
    Chicago, IL
    My friends, you all blow me away with your vision and your talent. Choosing was definately not an easy task...but here goes:

    Three points to Hippie by Joe Lorenzini

    Two points to The Stare by Michael Schuster

    One point to Lost in thought by Sommer

    A huge word of congratulations to all who submitted entries in this contest, your submission was creative and well thought out.
     
  4. tough one!

    I have to echo Frank's sentiments............this is a first for me and it was fun............its just that dang creativity and I thought it was a male thing, guess it is just me. LOL!!! Well done everyone.......I had to go back many times to try and figure this one out...

    3pts- CKnight - Dreaming of Birds - luv the composition, use of DOF, color, found it very captivating

    2pts - Joe Lornezini- Hippi - could definitely see this on a poster ;-) Luv the composition and what it does not show. Very well thought out!

    1pt
    - Chris101 - Pink Feathers - Beautiful background, makes the pink feathers stand out, shot at high ISO, clean look and beautiful colors, well done Chris!

    Honorable mention- Stare by MCS - man you have the creative juices, awesome framing and composition. Nicely done!
     
  5. Leigh

    Leigh

    Feb 19, 2005
    Alabama
    1st place--3 points--CKnight---"Dreaming of Birds"

    2nd place--2 points--Kevin Scott---"The End"

    3rd Place--1 point--MCS---"The Stare"


    You all did an outstanding job. This was a tough one....I'm excited to see who wins and even more excited to see what the next contest will be. Come on now, stretch our imaginations some more!!!!
     
  6. PGB

    PGB

    Jan 25, 2005
    3 points to CKnight "Dreaming of Birds"

    2 points to Shecks "I just want to be your friend"

    1 point to smera "SHARK"

    This was a very tough contest. The submissions were extremely creative and some just really funny. These contests make us look deep into our creativity to find a different side to ourselves, at least for me.

    Excellent work everyone.

    Thanks Greg for a great topic!
     
  7. Kevin Scott - The End - 3 points
    cknight - Dreaming of Birds - 2 points
    Smera - Shark - 1 point
     
  8. Chris101

    Chris101

    Feb 2, 2005
    Arizona
    1st place (3 points) for Michael 'mcs' - The Stare
    2nd place (2 points) for Roberto 'smera' - Shark !!!!
    3rd place (1 point) for Kevin 'Kevin Scott' - The End
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Mar 15, 2017
  9. 1st place - 3 points - Kevin Scott - The End

    2nd place - 2 points - Cris 101 - Pink feathers

    3rd place - 1 point - msc - The Stare
     
  10. smera

    smera

    103
    Aug 11, 2005
    Brasil
    1st place - 3 points - Kevin Scott - The End

    2nd place - 2 points - David Fink - Hoofing It

    3rd place - 1 point - Marcelo Guedes - Sentry[/b]
     
  11. JMartin

    JMartin Guest

    UHG! Very good contest topic and I missed it due to work!!!!

    There were many good entries again this contest, it was harder than ever to choose. My top three were:

    Chris101 - Pink Feathers

    MCS - The Stare

    Smera - Shark

    Great submissions, congrats to everyone that posted their photos.

    Joe
     
  12. my vote!

    Wow many great portions which combine to a very artistic whole challenge!

    Here's my vote for Challenge #10

    1st place: 3 points go to "The End" by Kevin Scott
    Great abstract Rear End! Although the owner might not consider this his best side? :wink:

    2nd place: 2 points go to "Shark" by smera
    Seems I'm into abstracts, this time. I hope you tilted the camera and not the bird! :wink:

    3rd place: 1 point goes to "Dreaming of Birds" by cknight
    Nice mellow mood, seems like he/she is dreaming of a roasted chickens :wink:

    Honorable mentions to:
    Chris 101 very abstract (and almost as good as your avatars), Philippe Roger (Great capture, but my cat mentioned it to be a little too explicit :wink:)
    and to all the other participants for showing such creativity!
     
  13. Nice job everyone...

    1st place: 3 points go to "Howard" by Patrick Bramlett
    In the spirit of the challenge this is perfectly done. Love the colors and the composition. Right on the money!

    2nd place: 2 points go to "Pink Feathers" by Chris101
    Looks like a studio shot. Quality is best of the group and considering the equipment and settings used, makes it that much more outstanding.

    3rd place: 1 point goes to ""Shark" by smera
    Colors, texture, background. Quality photograph. Well done.

    Honorable mentions to:
    David Fink: Love the lines and texture. Dbirdsong: If you had cropped it tighter you'd have my vote. Funny pic!. And Greg just because I have sooooo many of these shots!

    Congrats to all,

    _/oe
     
  14. My vote

    1st place (3 pts): Hoofing It by David Fink

    2nd place (2 pts): The Stare by Michael Shuster

    3rd place (1 pt.): The End by Kevin Scott

    Honorable Mention: Twoonie by Keith

    Good contest with lots of nice entries. Congratulations to all.
     
  15. cmpalmer

    cmpalmer

    301
    Jan 27, 2005
    Huntsville, AL
    1st place (3pts): Dreaming of Birds (cknight)
    2nd place (2pts): The End (Kevin Scott)
    3rd place (1pt): The Stare (MCS)

    Honorable mention: Any of the ones I didn't vote for -- great contest idea and a bunch of great entries!
     
  16. RFCGRAPHICS

    RFCGRAPHICS

    Apr 30, 2005
    Voting keeps getting harder and harder.
    My 2 cent opinion...........


    3 points - I Just Want to be Your Friend by Shecks

    2 points - Faster than I by Greg

    1 pont - Shark by Smera


    Regards

    RFC
     
  17. Fantastic submissions for this Challenge. Wish I had more votes to give!! Great work, everyone.

    Here are my extremely difficult decisions:

    1st (3 points) -- Hippie, by Joe Lorenzini
    2nd (2 points) -- The Stare, by Michael (MCS)
    3rd (1 point) -- Ssllrrppp, by Hans


    And honorable mentions to:

    Smera for Shark -- fabulous image
    Chris for Pink Feathers -- always love your stuff, man. (even if your avatars sometimes freak me out)
    Robert (RFCNikon) for Having a Bad Day
    Philippe for Friends

    Best wishes,

    David
     
  18. 3 points - Shark by Smera

    2 points - Faster than I by Greg

    1 pont - I Just Want to be Your Friend by Shecks
     
  19. Great entries!

    1st - 3pts ~ David Fink for Hoofing It

    2nd - 2pts ~ Smera for Shark

    3rd - 1pt ~ SButtrick for Parts is Parts

    Honorable mention to Greg's "Faster Than I" as I can definitely relate to that shot!! :wink:
     
  20. sfoxjohn

    sfoxjohn

    May 1, 2005
    Marlton, NJ
    I tried to judge first and foremost by faithfulness to the theme.

    1st (3 pts) Pink Feather by Chris

    I see only feathers, yet I know exactly what the whole is.

    2nd (2 pts) The end by Kevin

    Shows a little bit more of the whole.

    3rd (1 pt) Hoofing it by David

    Same comment as 2nd

    For HM I would choose The Stare by mcs for professional quality
    and Shark!!! by Smera. I probably would have made the Shark #2 or #3, but I'm not convinced it is a shark fin and hence not part of the whole - shark that is. If I'm wrong about this please accept my apologies.
     
Loading...
Similar Threads Forum Date
Cafe Challenge #70 - Submission Thread Challenge and Contests Forum Oct 15, 2009
Cafe Challenge #69 - Submission Thread Challenge and Contests Forum Sep 21, 2009
Cafe Challenge #10 results Challenge and Contests Forum Aug 20, 2005
Cafe Challenge #10 - Submission Thread Challenge and Contests Forum Jul 30, 2005
Cafe Challenge #10 - Topic Thread Challenge and Contests Forum Jul 30, 2005