Fake and bad cards, photo corruption, USB3, cables and more...

Growltiger

Administrator
Administrator
Joined
Apr 26, 2008
Messages
15,603
Location
Up in the hills, Gloucestershire, UK
I recently bought several new SD cards. Two 32 GB cards and a 128 GB card, all Sandisk Extreme, class 10, 45MB/sec. (Yes, that is Bytes not bits). Although I had bought from Amazon itself (not Amazon Marketplace, let alone Ebay), I decided to run some proper tests to make sure that they were not fake, and also that they worked perfectly, and at the advertised speed.

Fake cards are programmed to report incorrect "upgraded" sizes, so a 1GB card that failed testing might be sold as a 16GB card. If formatted in the camera it will still show 16GB and will appear to work, at first. Obviously if you keep writing data to it, your photos will go into a black hole from which they can never be retrieved.

I used this software:
http://www.heise.de/download/h2testw.html
It is rather slow but very thorough. It writes different data each time so it can spot if the incorrect data is retrieved. If you have any concerns about your cards, run this test. To work it, first delete every file and folder on the card. Note what drive letter it shows up as. Click on English unless you are German. Select the correct drive, then Write and Verify. If it is a large card, allow a few hours, perhaps leave it running overnight. (Afterwards format the card in the camera - the program leaves it full.)

The program sometimes reported that my cards were faulty. I eventually pinned it down to a type of USB3 extension cable. (With an old USB2 reader attached to my laptop, all was well.) I use USpeed and Anker USB3 readers that work with all card types. I have multiple USB3 extension cables for my PC which is on the floor. I have had problems before with a particular type of USB3 extension cable and had returned some, and had thrown away some. But I had continued to use the cables that appeared to work. I now found that was a mistake and I have thrown all my cables of that type away. I also have Startech.com USB3 extension cables and they do work correctly.

So everything now works perfectly. If I had not checked this, sooner or later I would have had corrupted photos, and would not have known whether to blame the camera, the card, the reader, the cable or the computer.
 

Growltiger

Administrator
Administrator
Joined
Apr 26, 2008
Messages
15,603
Location
Up in the hills, Gloucestershire, UK
Sounds like a good way to securely wipe a memory card as well.
Yes, except that if there is a fractional area left at the very end of the card it doesn't test it, so it would not be overwritten. If this happens it puts up a warning.
So you should still use purpose built security software to overwrite your data, if it is essential to keep it secret.
 
Joined
May 27, 2013
Messages
3,348
Location
Cornpatch
...........So you should still use purpose built security software to overwrite your data, if it is essential to keep it secret.

I use a cordless drill and ¼" bit.:ROFLMAO:

Now, if someone has a way to test the actual speed of a card............
 

Growltiger

Administrator
Administrator
Joined
Apr 26, 2008
Messages
15,603
Location
Up in the hills, Gloucestershire, UK
The program reports both the write and read speeds. The actual values shown for my cards were only marginally less than the rated speed, I got about 43-44MB/sec.
An older Transcend card I tested was only about 15.
 

Growltiger

Administrator
Administrator
Joined
Apr 26, 2008
Messages
15,603
Location
Up in the hills, Gloucestershire, UK
I received two new Startech.com cables today to replace the bad cables and repeated the tests. Everything works perfectly.

I also compared the card speeds using the same card and card reader, but on my large system with USB3, and on my laptop with USB2.
The cards are rated at 45MB/s, Class 10.
With USB3 I got only a little less, about 42 writing and 43 reading. A good performance.
With USB2 I got 15 writing and 29 reading.
 

Growltiger

Administrator
Administrator
Joined
Apr 26, 2008
Messages
15,603
Location
Up in the hills, Gloucestershire, UK
Yes, that is good news, everything is OK. Now format the card and you can then use it.
But it does leave you with no explanation for why it went wrong. If that card does it again, I would bin it.
 
Joined
Apr 12, 2006
Messages
12,349
Location
Central Georgia, USA
Thanks for the education. There was a sale from Sandisk last week on refurbished cards would anyone buy those? I almost bought a small one, 16 GB. Hum, does anyone beside me think using small in referencing a 16 GB card a bit odd ? remember when we paid a 1000$ a GB.:eek:
 

Latest threads

Top Bottom