Help me make a decision !

Discussion in 'Lens Lust' started by equetefue, Nov 16, 2005.

  1. equetefue

    equetefue

    489
    Sep 29, 2005
    Kissimmee, FL
    trying to decide which is the better buy.

    Nikon 80-200 f2.8 AF-D

    or

    Sigma 70-200mm f/2.8 EX DG APO HSM

    HELP !
     
  2. I was faced with the same decision a while back. I ultimately settled on the 80-200 Nikon 2-ring version. The Sigma, with HSM, is probably a faster focuser but I managed fine with my 80-200. As for quality, the Nikon is a killer. Shots extremely sharp and pleasing to the eye. Sigma, from what I've heard from others who own it, sometimes has a slight color cast. May not be a big issue for you though.

    I don't regret for a minute my decision going with the Nikon. I just recently got the 70-200VR and am debating if I want to keep the 80-200, since it's that good, or sell it.
     
  3. equetefue

    equetefue

    489
    Sep 29, 2005
    Kissimmee, FL
    which is the 2 ring version ?
     
  4. This is the 2-ring version here.

    There was an older version that was a push-pull type and there was also a 2-ring version that was AF-S. The newest model is not AF-S.
     
  5. The Sigma has a number of fans, and, though I've never used one, I've seen great shots from it, and it's assuredly a fine lens. My experience has been with the Nikon 80-200/2.8 (2 ring version), and I've enjoyed it enormously since upgrading from the 70-300 AFD. I use it (sometimes with a Kenko 1.4X teleconverter) for my nature shots...

    37325925.

    View attachment 18344

    View attachment 18345

    View attachment 18346

    View attachment 18347

    View attachment 18348

    and also for my hummingbird pictures.

    View attachment 18349

    View attachment 18350

    View attachment 18351

    It's also useful for sports, but it really excels at people pictures, both posed and candids.

    View attachment 18352

    View attachment 18353

    View attachment 18354

    View attachment 18355

    It's quite a lens... versatile, and sharp from tip to tip across its aperture and zoom range. If you decide to buy one, I'm sure you'll enjoy it.
     
Loading...
Similar Threads Forum Date
Please help with lens decision... Lens Lust Oct 2, 2012
Upgrade decision, help me make up my mind! Lens Lust Apr 1, 2010
Needing help making some decisions... Lens Lust Nov 4, 2007
Need Help on making a decision. Lens Lust Feb 1, 2007