Tim, I'm not sure but I think I like this one better - may be easier if you could do a side by side ? One thing though about this IMO and im far from an expert is that your foreground interest (large rock I assume), is now just a blur, so not certain that works or adds to the scene ? The blurring around the edges does draw my eye into the photo though, which is what I think I like, apologies for the confused reply !