Lens for family vacation

Discussion in 'Lens Lust' started by inukshuk, Apr 6, 2007.

  1. I've already got a good collection of prime lens from f1.4-f2.8, but want one lens to carry on my D100 for vacations. I've come down to two models.
    -Sigma APO 50-150mm F2.8 EX DC HSM
    -Nikkor 18-200mm f/3.5-5.6G IF-ED

    I know the 50-150 is a faster lens but doesn't have the range of the 18-200, so which way to go?? Would the 50-150 be good enough for an all purpose one only lens to carry around?
  2. ffb2t


    Jan 16, 2006
    IMO your 30 is perfect. If it must be a zoom, your 18-50. No need for more and no need to buy a special lens.
  3. go with the 18/200, I bought it for a trip to europe and was going to sell it the minute i got back, I still have it. I thought it was too slow to suit me, but it worked very well for an all in one lens. I did take a 50MM1.8 for interior shots, museums and such.
  4. Glideslope


    Feb 8, 2006
    18-200. Vacations =Handheld shooting=VR.
  5. jaleel


    Apr 3, 2007
    Toronto, Canada
    i'd recommend the 18-200 VR as well

    i took a tokina 12-24 also but used the 18-200 90% of the time while i was in the uk
  6. gadgetguy11


    Nov 16, 2005
    18-200 is a definite!


    if budget allows and you want a little more telephoto, add the 70-300VR!!

    Both are great. The 70-300VR is, in my opinion, the lowest priced stellar lens Nikon has introduced in a long time!
  7. mingaun


    Jun 13, 2006
    Its a difficult question. As for me when i go on vacation i find that most of my shots were done in the 18-135 range. I rarely need the reach of 150-200. So it really boils down to the type of shots you like to do. For me it is usually landscape and some candid shots.

    Actually the 18-200 is a versatile lens thats perfect for this type of things but looking at your list, i feel there is no need. In fact if anything, go for the second option of Sigma 50-150 and coupled with the 18-50, youre all set for a great vacation. But if you only plan to take one lens, then i am afraid nothing beats the 18-200VR.
  8. photogfellow

    photogfellow Guest

    As John just said.....the 18-200VR is the best all-around-walk-around lens, and the 70-300VR is a BEAUTY (my personal favorite)
  9. gugs


    Feb 24, 2006
    and another vote for the 18-200VR
  10. I have the 18-200VR and consider it the perfect vacation/travel lens.
  11. Donzo98


    Nov 10, 2005
    Merrick, NY
    Agree completely...:biggrin:
  12. I travel with a Promaster (Tamron rebadge) 28-300 f/3.5-6.3. It's a little slow but surprisingly sharp. I don't miss the wide end at all but I also don't travel to Europe either... and my wife doesn't like it when I carry more than the camera and one lens, lens changes take away from shopping time i guess, lol. I'm really interested to see Tamron's new 28-300mm w/ their equivalent of VR hit the market... if it hits under $500 there's a good chance I'll grab one.

    Since you have a 18-50mm I'd strongly consider the 15-150mm f/2.8 and carry both. You can always leave one or the other in your hotel/hostel/tent/tp/igloo if you know it won't see use that particular day
  13. I do love my 18-200 but am finding I am starting to rely more and more on my 12-24 and 50mm prime. If Nikon could design a 24-80 at the same size and IQ as my WA, I would be ecstatic!
  14. Nuteshack

    Nuteshack Guest

    make sure u r used to whatever lens you purchase
Similar Threads Forum Date
New High End lens family from Carl Zeiss Lens Lust Sep 19, 2012
Lens suggestion for a family trip to Orlando, FL Lens Lust Jun 6, 2011
Lens for outdoor family portraits? Lens Lust Sep 28, 2010
A new lens joins the family... Lens Lust Jun 17, 2010
What's a good DX family portrait lens? Lens Lust Sep 1, 2009