Lens for family vacation

Discussion in 'Lens Lust' started by inukshuk, Apr 6, 2007.

  1. I've already got a good collection of prime lens from f1.4-f2.8, but want one lens to carry on my D100 for vacations. I've come down to two models.
    -Sigma APO 50-150mm F2.8 EX DC HSM
    -Nikkor 18-200mm f/3.5-5.6G IF-ED

    I know the 50-150 is a faster lens but doesn't have the range of the 18-200, so which way to go?? Would the 50-150 be good enough for an all purpose one only lens to carry around?
     
  2. ffb2t

    ffb2t

    420
    Jan 16, 2006
    CA
    IMO your 30 is perfect. If it must be a zoom, your 18-50. No need for more and no need to buy a special lens.
     
  3. go with the 18/200, I bought it for a trip to europe and was going to sell it the minute i got back, I still have it. I thought it was too slow to suit me, but it worked very well for an all in one lens. I did take a 50MM1.8 for interior shots, museums and such.
     
  4. Glideslope

    Glideslope

    787
    Feb 8, 2006
    NY
    18-200. Vacations =Handheld shooting=VR.
     
  5. jaleel

    jaleel

    90
    Apr 3, 2007
    Toronto, Canada
    i'd recommend the 18-200 VR as well

    i took a tokina 12-24 also but used the 18-200 90% of the time while i was in the uk
     
  6. gadgetguy11

    gadgetguy11

    Nov 16, 2005
    Kentucky
    18-200 is a definite!

    then...

    if budget allows and you want a little more telephoto, add the 70-300VR!!

    Both are great. The 70-300VR is, in my opinion, the lowest priced stellar lens Nikon has introduced in a long time!
     
  7. mingaun

    mingaun

    163
    Jun 13, 2006
    Malaysia
    Its a difficult question. As for me when i go on vacation i find that most of my shots were done in the 18-135 range. I rarely need the reach of 150-200. So it really boils down to the type of shots you like to do. For me it is usually landscape and some candid shots.

    Actually the 18-200 is a versatile lens thats perfect for this type of things but looking at your list, i feel there is no need. In fact if anything, go for the second option of Sigma 50-150 and coupled with the 18-50, youre all set for a great vacation. But if you only plan to take one lens, then i am afraid nothing beats the 18-200VR.
     
  8. photogfellow

    photogfellow Guest

    As John just said.....the 18-200VR is the best all-around-walk-around lens, and the 70-300VR is a BEAUTY (my personal favorite)
     
  9. gugs

    gugs

    490
    Feb 24, 2006
    Belgium
    and another vote for the 18-200VR
     
  10. I have the 18-200VR and consider it the perfect vacation/travel lens.
     
  11. Donzo98

    Donzo98

    Nov 10, 2005
    Merrick, NY
    Agree completely...:biggrin:
     
  12. I travel with a Promaster (Tamron rebadge) 28-300 f/3.5-6.3. It's a little slow but surprisingly sharp. I don't miss the wide end at all but I also don't travel to Europe either... and my wife doesn't like it when I carry more than the camera and one lens, lens changes take away from shopping time i guess, lol. I'm really interested to see Tamron's new 28-300mm w/ their equivalent of VR hit the market... if it hits under $500 there's a good chance I'll grab one.

    Since you have a 18-50mm I'd strongly consider the 15-150mm f/2.8 and carry both. You can always leave one or the other in your hotel/hostel/tent/tp/igloo if you know it won't see use that particular day
     
  13. I do love my 18-200 but am finding I am starting to rely more and more on my 12-24 and 50mm prime. If Nikon could design a 24-80 at the same size and IQ as my WA, I would be ecstatic!
     
  14. Nuteshack

    Nuteshack Guest

    make sure u r used to whatever lens you purchase
     
Loading...
Similar Threads Forum Date
New High End lens family from Carl Zeiss Lens Lust Sep 19, 2012
Lens suggestion for a family trip to Orlando, FL Lens Lust Jun 6, 2011
Lens for outdoor family portraits? Lens Lust Sep 28, 2010
A new lens joins the family... Lens Lust Jun 17, 2010
What's a good DX family portrait lens? Lens Lust Sep 1, 2009