Melissa

Terri,
The second is maybe a bit too posed looking, but the first is really great!! Nice and natural portrait of a beautiful young lady. Your lighting is excellent too.

I think I would like the third photo better if the skin tone of the arms was close to the tone of her face. You might try selecting her arms with the marquee tool and doing a levels adjustment to darken them slightly.....unless of course you like them just the way they are!

 

Nice Terri. My pick is #1. Good job on the conversion. LIke Stuart said in #3 it would probably look better if the arms were closer in tone to the face. I think it would be my favorite of the 3 they did.

 

That's a good set for a beginner, well done Terry.
#1 is very good.
#2 would benefit from tighter crop at the bottom as the "fur" the model elbows are resting on look quite odd here IMHO. BTW I like the pose on #2, the hands are very nice as is the smile.
#3 doesn't work for me at all, sorry.

 

Terri, good shots! #1 would be my pick also. Like the light and her look in it.

 

Terri............ has to be #1 for me............ a great image!

G

 

Terri I like the second one better. However, your subject should be wearing black so that it doesn't clash with your beautiful throw. JMHO.

 

Terri,

You've captured her eyes so well in all three that it's hard to move beyond them.

But I have . . .

The second does look posed, but it's a great pose. I love it. My only suggestions are to try either a square crop from the top down to the middle of the "V" on her shirt or a 4:5 crop by balancing the right side with the left and then cutting just above the throw.

On the third there's something in her hair just above the part. I didn't notice it at first but, now that I have I wonder . . . do you have a rabbit?  

 

hmmm. I like #3 really, maybe a bit more contrast.

 

I have to go with the consensus. Let me just add that #1 is very good! You are doing well with your lighting, Terri.

 

My thoughts exactly. #1 would be my fav and the others look great as well. As mentioned earlier, great job on the conversion.

 

I love #1, that's just a really great shot. Everything about it just works. #2 the pose is a little too contrived for my tastes.

 

Terri, I love #1...very nice natural light...

#2, perfect exposure and processing, but a little too posed for me.

#3...agree with Stu about the skin tones...but I think if you convert to B+W, it might give a whole different feel...

 

Terry, you have a beautiful daughter and I think the first two images capture that very well. Not so keen on the third one - just a personal preference really.

 

Well, if you and your daughter like it, then keep it in :smile:

 

You are really doing well with your lighting Terri. My favorite of the series is #1, you have done a good job on the conversion.