Sigma 80-400 vs. Nikon 80-400 vs. ?

Discussion in 'Lens Lust' started by DanielD, Jun 1, 2007.

  1. Hello, as I noticed some kind of new to me "halo" around high contrast edges on my Sigma at 400mm wide open, I eventually did a test series using my D200.
    Set up on a tripod, using MLU and remote shutter and out came the below series, each a 100% crop.
    I think you can clearly see that kind of halo I mean on the leaf's edge.

    I'm curious to see such a series for the Nikkor (or maybe the Sigma 120-300 :rolleyes:) or other lenses around 400mm to get a feeling how normal that IQ is. Downscaled to web size it looks quite well, so from looking at the usual posted image size, you can hardly get a clue how IQ is actually for that particular lens, wide open.


    As you can see on the other leaf edges, that effect is mainly (only?) visible on edges of high contrast, i.e. some bright objects.

Similar Threads Forum Date
Nikon 200-500 vs Sigma 150-600 Sport Lens Lust Nov 29, 2017
Sigma 300-800 vs Nikon 500 f4 VR-G with TC14EIII Lens Lust May 10, 2017
Look vs. Sharpness a.k.a. 1.4G vs. Art Lens Lust May 3, 2017
Nikon 105 1.4 vs Sigma 135 1.8 Lens Lust Apr 17, 2017
Buy Nikon 24 ƒ1.4 vs. Sigma 24 Art for "3D-ness"? Lens Lust Mar 17, 2016