Which catches your eye first – Light, Color or Gesture?

Discussion in 'General Discussion' started by jklofft, May 31, 2011.

Which catches your eye first – Light, Color or Gesture?

  1. Light

    62.9%
  2. Color

    17.1%
  3. Gesture

    20.0%
  1. Jay Maisel talks about light, color and gesture as aspects of a great photograph. Sometimes one of these three is so powerful that we are drawn to take a photograph, but most of the time it seems our brain is wired to focus first on just one of the three. So when you out and about, which generally catches your photographic eye first?
     
  2. think about this now i would say - colour and light first
     
  3. cwilt

    cwilt

    Apr 24, 2005
    Denver, CO
    It depends on what I am shooting. If its people its gesture first then light. I usually see these in black and white so color is an after thought. For landscapes its all about light and color. Animals are a combination.
     
  4. hands down light - before my eyes can even focus on the subject its the way the light paints the image that catches my eye...

    With that said - a picture of a beautiful woman will always draw my eye regardless of light, color or gesture =)
     
  5. Gesture.
    I'm a street-shooter so for me it's all about the story. So even if the colour and light are less than optimal, for me the story trumps all.
     
  6. Debbie H

    Debbie H

    Aug 23, 2007
    Missouri
    Yes I would say light first then color.
     
  7. Seneca

    Seneca

    Dec 4, 2006
    Texas!
    Always light...it's the one thing that I as a photographer would like to master. I have a friend who is a master photographer, he shoots all times of the day and does it so beautifully. Doesn't matter how bright the sun is shining down, he manages to get perfect, not blown out shots. Of course he does have 2 assistants too. That's what happens when your a $500,000 a year photographer. Geez.
     
  8. I voted light, but in my mind, light and color are to closely connected to separate, at least from the color perspective. Color is so dependent upon the lighting. Poor lighting, flat lighting will affect the color. So I guess light first, then color, then gesture.
     
  9. Ryan_T

    Ryan_T

    Mar 24, 2011
    Canada
    Light.

    Which is somewhat disappointing when nothing good can be made out of it. Sometimes there is such a thing as uninteresting or unattractive subjects, no matter how much good light is on it.
     
  10. Without light, you cannot see color and gesture :wink:
     
  11. HenryVIII

    HenryVIII

    736
    Sep 4, 2010
    Columbia, MD
    Gesture.

    Joseph, that kind of light is a given, like gravity. I believe the OP was asking about it from a technical and compositional perspective.
     
  12. Yes, thank you
     
  13. Rob Zijlstra

    Rob Zijlstra A Koffie Drinker

    999
    Nov 5, 2008
    Netherlands
    Light, light and after that light!
     
  14. It is true that colors, especially warm colors, tend to catch our eyes but, when the media was b&w, light was what inspired a photographer to take good pictures. Obviously, light brings out tonalities but I will not discuss that.
    "Concentrate on seeing the nuisances of light and your pictures will stir the soul."
    Jack Dykinga.

    William Rodriguez
    Miami, Florida.
     
  15. oh okay.. it's still light for me. I almost rarely notice a nice gesture or color, but no matter how flat the scene is, if the light is dramatic, it's guaranteed to catch my attention.
     
  16. Same here. Not until I review my images on screen do I notice the colors and how they affect me. I need to start working on that pre-shutter release, :smile:.
     
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.