Which version do you prefer?

[Ping279]

Shot these today, all natural light with some fill from a white card.

Subscribe to see EXIF info for this image (if available)

View attachment 234821

 

[little big man]

#1 - they look so ethereal!

Sean

 

[eL eSs Vee]

Wow! Beautiful! I like them both! But, you want us to choose only one. . . .

If you have a version of number one with a little more headroom, it'd go from great to excellent and I'd choose that one. I hope this helps. :smile:

 

[nuccifamily]

Very cool. I prefer #1.

 

[Ping279]

Wow! Beautiful! I like them both! But, you want us to choose only one. . . .

If you have a version of number one with a little more headroom, it'd go from great to excellent and I'd choose that one. I hope this helps. :smile:

Well as much as i try at photoshop, I just can't seem to add in some headroom to the first picture. My cloning/patching skills must just not be up to par. I dont have another that is like that one so I guess I will just have to live with it.

 

[StL_Don]

To make a choice I'm going to make an assumption and that is that this is a product shot for an ad.
And with that in mind #2 gets the not. It grabs the viewer's attention better and it portrays the word "energize" which is on the bottle.

Both are very well done.

Don

 

[Ping279]

Thanks Don. It actually was what I was going for. I want to do commercial/advertising photography as my profession and so product shots that I take normally are for ads in my mind.

 

[truflip]

I like the second one personally.

 

[veloman]

# 2 for me,diagonals are always stronger.

V.

 

[DM Rosner]

I prefer the first, but would like it a little straighter--or, OTOH, at an angle but perhaps not quite as severe a diagonal as #2.

For me, #2 is a bit over the top.

 

[Ping279]

Well here is my version of the advertisement.

Subscribe to see EXIF info for this image (if available)